• Sources: discussion
  • Summary: The October DIS ballot drew 13 votes in favor, 9 against and 12 abstentions, so it missed ISO's limit of 25 percent negative votes. Bjarne Stroustrup and co-authors call the P2900 Contracts design an existential threat to C++. Committee member Andreas Fertig says the no votes broke trust after repeated majority approvals. WG21 meets next week in Buzios, Brazil. It can remove Contracts, move them into a technical specification, or revise and vote again, and the standard may slip to 2027.
  • Why it matters: Library hardening already built on Contracts may be undone, and toolchain teams planning C++26 support face a delayed or reshaped standard.
  • Background: Contracts let code declare preconditions, postconditions and assertions that can be checked at run time, an idea long present in Ada and Eiffel. A version was pulled from C++20 late over concerns about dangerous defaults. The Draft International Standard ballot is the next-to-last ISO stage, where national bodies approve the technical content, and failing it is rare in C++ history.
  • Follow-up: WG21 meeting in Buzios, Brazil, the week of 2026-11-16.